Subscribe to JamesPod at jamespod.com
On this episode of JamesPod, host James Abrenio sits down with Matt Royer — former President of the Virginia Young Democrats, former Campaign Manager, and writer of the political Substack By the Ballot — for an unflinching look at the challenges facing Democrats after the 2024 election.
Royer explains why Democrats are struggling with younger voters, pointing to a 2.4 million net loss of registered Democrats since 2020 compared to a 2 million increase for Republicans. He argues that the party too often communicates in overly academic or “weak” language, failing to give voters clear, relatable reasons to support them. Instead of manufacturing new “Democratic Joe Rogans,” Royer suggests engaging existing platforms with built-in progressive audiences.
The conversation explores:
Media & Messaging: How the loss of media dominance since the Reagan-era Fairness Doctrine continues to haunt Democrats, and why authentic, conversational messaging beats focus-grouped soundbites.
Core Issues: Housing, clean water, healthcare, education, and wages as unifying themes that can transcend identity divisions if communicated effectively.
Generational Tensions: Millennials and Gen Z now make up the largest share of the Democratic base (34–35%), yet younger leaders like David Hogg, Malcolm Kenyatta, and Zohran Mandani often face resistance despite electoral legitimacy.
Case Study: North Carolina: At just 25, Anderson Clayton built coalitions in rural North Carolina that delivered statewide Democratic wins through authentic local messaging rather than celebrity endorsements.
Consulting & Trust: The “Speaking with American Men” project and the prevalence of scam PACs illustrate how political consulting often enriches insiders rather than candidates, eroding voter trust.
Young Men & Masculinity: A candid discussion about toxic online influences like Andrew Tate and the need for positive male role models who frame success as service to community, not dominance.
Culture Wars & Distractions: With fewer than 10 trans girls in Virginia sports over four years, Royer stresses resisting Republican framings while focusing on education, safety, and teacher pay.
Virginia Politics: From Spanberger vs. Sears to September’s elections, Royer highlights how Democrats must navigate a media environment tilted toward MAGA narratives.
The episode closes with a call to action: embrace intergenerational leadership, elevate authentic local voices, and give voters reasons to vote for Democrats — not just against Republicans.
